How to be consistent with working out: set a minimum so small that a bad day cannot beat it, then treat everything above it as a bonus. Eugen Sandow’s own book built that idea in, with short sessions and tiny increases. The routine below is Copy John’s adaptation of it, not Sandow’s prescription.

Eugen Sandow seated with arms crossed in a studio portrait by Benjamin J. Falk, the strongman who wrote a home dumb-bell routine for being consistent with working out
Eugen Sandow, photographed by Benjamin J. Falk. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Why the usual advice fails

Read the pages that rank for this search and the advice converges fast. Pick something you enjoy. Put it in the diary. Find a friend. Track it. Start small. Take rest days. None of that is wrong. All of it treats consistency as a supply problem: find enough motivation and the sessions will happen.

Consistency actually breaks at specific moments. The third day, when the novelty has gone and your legs hurt. The tired Wednesday. The missed Friday that quietly becomes a missed fortnight. Generic tips rarely say which of those moments they are aimed at.

They are also vague about time. The best-known real measurement is a 2010 study by Phillippa Lally and colleagues in the European Journal of Social Psychology. Ninety-six volunteers chose an eating, drinking or activity habit and reported on it daily for twelve weeks. Reaching a plateau in automaticity took a median of 66 days, but individuals ranged from 18 to 254. The same paper found that missing a single opportunity did not materially affect the process.

Those figures describe everyday habits in general, not workouts specifically. They are still the honest starting point. Expect months rather than weeks, and expect to wobble. A plan for the wobble matters more than a plan for the good days.

What Eugen Sandow actually did

Eugen Sandow (1867 to 1925) was a professional strongman who turned his fame into a business: schools of physical culture in London and Manchester, a monthly magazine, a correspondence course and a book, Strength and How to Obtain It. The book is on Project Gutenberg. It is a sales document as much as a manual, because he sold the equipment it recommends and prints his own testimonials. Read everything below with that in mind.

It is also not a diary. There is no log of how many days Sandow himself trained, and I am not claiming one. It is instructions to pupils, and those instructions are unusually frank about why people quit.

He named the drop-off. In Chapter IV he warns that “after the first two or three days the enthusiasm, perhaps, wears off.” Then comes a stiff period in which the pupil “is inclined to think that he cannot be bothered to proceed.” His remedy is thin: “Don’t be overcome by apparent difficulties; if you wish to succeed, go forward; never draw back.” The diagnosis is the useful part.

He refused to fix the time of day. Also Chapter IV: “I do not, therefore, lay down a hard and fast rule of time.” The golden rule was to select “such part of the day as suits you best,” leaving a gap after meals.

He wanted feedback to be enjoyable. He advises exercising before a looking-glass, because “to see the muscles at work, and to mark their steady development, is itself a help and a pleasure.”

He preferred short, honest sessions. Chapter IX: “A quarter of an hour’s conscientious work is better than an hour spent in ‘going through the motions’ in a desultory fashion.” In Chapter IV he complains of pupils who exercise “three or four or even more” hours a day and see little improvement. His rule for growth was to raise the load, not the time: when the whole series took “much over half-an-hour,” start again with heavier bells or springs.

He made the increases small. The Chapter IX tables give a starting count and a rate. The table for girls of seventeen and over starts the first exercise at 20 movements with each arm and adds one every other day, with a ceiling of 80. That is sixty steps at one per two days: 120 days, about seventeen weeks, to reach the top. The tables, he says, are “only intended as a guide.” His table for young men climbs faster, adding five a day to the first exercise, and that one I would not copy.

He built a minimum into the equipment. This is the piece that matters most. In Chapter V he describes his “Grip” dumb-bell, two halves held apart by a spring. He admits what happens on a bad day: a pupil who feels “a bit off-colour,” or is worried about business, and uses ordinary bells, exercises “in a desultory and half-hearted manner.” With the spring, however preoccupied the pupil is, he must grip, so “the amount of power exerted can never fall below a known and easily regulated minimum.” It was also a product he sold, so treat the claims as a pitch. The design idea still holds.

He measured monthly, not daily. Chapter XII gives a chart for chest, arms, waist, thighs and calves, and advises pupils “to keep a careful record of these month by month.”

Why it worked

A caution first. There is no controlled evidence that Sandow’s pupils stuck with it better than anyone else, only his own claims and the letters he chose to print. What follows is why the design is sound, not proof that it worked for them.

A floor beats a target. On a bad day you no longer decide whether to train, because the minimum was decided in advance. The CDC’s adult guidelines back the principle: “Some physical activity is better than none.”

Short sessions are cheaper to start. Fifteen minutes is an easier yes than an hour, and finishing with something in reserve makes tomorrow’s yes easier too. That second part is my reading, not his claim.

Small steps stay under the injury line. Sandow himself wrote that “it is always better to use bells too light than too heavy,” because heavy ones “are liable to cause strains and other injuries.” Nobody stays consistent with a sore shoulder.

The wobble was expected. Being told on day one that day three will feel bad turns a sign of failure into an item on the schedule. Lally’s finding that one missed opportunity did not materially change the process points the same way.

How to be consistent with working out this week

This is my adaptation of Sandow’s ideas, not a routine he set out. Numbers marked as mine are mine.

  1. Write your floor, not your goal. Pick one thing you can do on your worst day in under five minutes: ten squats, ten press-ups, a brisk lap of the block. Choose movements you can stand, since dread is the real enemy. On a bad day you do the floor, tick the calendar and stop. That is the spring in his dumb-bell, minus the spring.
  2. Choose the slot that suits you, then keep it for four weeks. Sandow left the time of day to the pupil, and so should you. Morning, lunch or evening is fine. Leave a couple of hours after a big meal, as he advised, and stop renegotiating the slot every day.
  3. Write down the third day. Put a note on the calendar: “Day 3: expect stiffness and boredom. Do the floor.” He warned pupils about exactly that dip, so when it arrives it is the plan working.
  4. Keep sessions short and add tiny steps. Start with fifteen minutes. Add one repetition to one exercise every other day, the pace of his table for girls, and stop at a ceiling you set in advance. If a session drifts past about half an hour, make it harder rather than longer, if you can do so safely.
  5. Tell one person and measure once a month. Text a friend after each session, or book a class. Sandow’s schools worked the same way: he says he personally examined pupils from time to time. Tick a calendar daily, but measure or weigh yourself only monthly, as his chart did. If you miss a day, do the floor tomorrow.
  6. Add two proper sessions a week. The floor keeps the habit alive, but it is not enough for health by itself. The CDC recommends 150 minutes of moderate-intensity activity a week for adults, plus muscle-strengthening on 2 days. Its own example is 30 minutes on five days, which leaves two rest days. Five-minute floors alone add up to 35 minutes, so grow the longer sessions over months. If you have a heart or joint condition, or have been inactive for years, ask your GP before you increase anything. Sandow himself said a doctor should be consulted in cases of “organic weakness.”

What not to copy

Do not treat aching as a target. Chapter IX says to “exercise until the muscles ache,” short of feeling “thoroughly ‘blown’ and exhausted.” Ache is not a measure of progress. Sharp or persistent pain means stop and get it looked at.

Do not repeat his claim about quitting. In Chapter VII he writes that “it is indeed better never to have exercised at all than to exercise for a few years and then drop it entirely.” Current CDC guidance says the opposite: some activity is better than none. Coming back after a break beats never starting.

Do not copy his numbers. The tables were written for one-pound to ten-pound dumb-bells in the 1890s, and the young men’s table adds five movements a day. That is faster than most beginners should climb.

Do not believe his results. He says he “put an inch on the height of a young fellow in three weeks,” and he cites insurance medicals and pupils’ letters. All of it is self-reported and unverifiable, in a book that sells a course. His claim that “brain will do as much as dumb-bells” is also not a licence to swap training for flexing while you read.

You do not need the spring dumb-bell, or his cold bath every morning. The floor is the idea. The kit is the sales pitch.

Frequently asked questions

How to get consistent with working out?

Get through the first three weeks with a floor rather than a target. Sandow’s own text expected enthusiasm to fade after two or three days and told pupils to push through it. Lally’s data suggests the habit itself takes months, so judge yourself on whether you did the floor, not on how the session felt.

How to be consistent with working out at home?

Sandow’s system needed only light dumb-bells. In a letter of 29 July 1893, which he printed in the book, Lieutenant-Colonel G. M. Fox, then Her Majesty’s Inspector of Gymnasia, praised “the absence of expensive and cumbrous apparatus.” In Chapter II he also says private individuals were “working steadily in their own homes.” Leave your kit where you will see it, and keep the floor small enough that the front room is never the obstacle.

How to be more consistent with working out?

Fix what happens after a miss, not just before it. Do the floor the next day and carry on. In the Lally study, missing one opportunity did not materially affect the habit-forming process, so a single skipped session is not the emergency it feels like.

How to stay consistent with working out and diet?

Treat them as two habits and start one at a time. Sandow’s book mixes exercise with advice on temperance and cold baths, and I would not copy that mix. That is my view, not his. For a change in eating beyond the basics, ask a GP or a registered dietitian.

Sources


This is part of Copy John’s guide to how to stop being lazy.

Get one of these a day, free →

More like this