How to follow through on what you say you will do: promise less, give every promise a named person and a date, and double your time estimate. Samuel Johnson met a printer’s deadline twice a week for two years, yet called his private resolutions fifty-five years of doing nothing. The difference was who was waiting.

Portrait of Samuel Johnson by Joshua Reynolds, 1772; Johnson's kept and missed deadlines show how to follow through on what you say you will do
Samuel Johnson, by Joshua Reynolds, 1772. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Why the usual advice fails

The usual advice is a character speech. Your word is your bond. Integrity matters. People who break promises lose trust. All true, and none of it news to the person who has just missed a third deadline. They already feel bad. Feeling worse is not a method.

The speech also assumes that following through is one skill, which you either have or lack. It is not. Most people who “never follow through” are reliable in some settings and hopeless in others. They turn up for the client and skip the gym. They file the tax return and never start the novel. The useful question is what the kept promises have that the broken ones do not.

Then there is the promise itself, which is usually wrong before you break it. In 1994 the psychologists Roger Buehler, Dale Griffin and Michael Ross asked 37 students how long their final-year thesis would take. The average guess was 33.9 days. The average result was 55.5 days, and only about 30 per cent finished in the time they had predicted. Even the students’ worst-case guess, 48.6 days on average, was too short. Nobody in that room was lying. They were just quoting a date for a version of the job in which nothing went wrong.

So “just keep your word” skips two things: why you keep some promises and not others, and how the date got so wrong in the first place. One man’s record shows both unusually well, because his friends wrote down his deadlines and he wrote down his failures.

What Samuel Johnson actually did

Samuel Johnson (1709 to 1784) compiled A Dictionary of the English Language, published in 1755. Most of what follows comes from James Boswell’s Life of Samuel Johnson (1791) and from Johnson’s own private diary, printed after his death as Prayers and Meditations. His record splits cleanly into three kinds of promise.

Promises with someone waiting that week: kept. Boswell records that Johnson’s essay paper, The Rambler, first appeared on Tuesday 20 March 1750 and that he kept it going “without interruption, every Tuesday and Friday” until March 1752. He did this while compiling the Dictionary and while suffering what Boswell calls “constitutional indolence” and “depression of spirits”. Many of the essays, Boswell says on Johnson’s own authority, were “written in haste as the moment pressed” and printed without his reading them over.

The same pattern shows in smaller stories. His friend Bennet Langton remembered Johnson, on a visit to Oxford, asking how long it was until the post went out. Told half an hour, he said “then we shall do very well”, sat down and finished an essay for The Idler that had to be in London the next day. In 1759, after his mother died, he wrote the short novel Rasselas. The printer William Strahan told Boswell it was written to pay for her funeral and her small debts. Johnson told the painter Joshua Reynolds he wrote it “in the evenings of one week” and sent it to the press in portions as it was written. That one-week figure is Johnson’s own claim, passed on second-hand, so treat it as his account and not a measured fact.

Big promises with a far-off date: kept, but years late. The booksellers who commissioned the Dictionary agreed to pay him £1,575. Boswell reports a conversation in which Johnson’s friend Dr Adams asked how he could possibly finish it in three years. Johnson replied: “Sir, I have no doubt that I can do it in three years.” When Adams pointed out that the French Academy’s forty members had needed forty years, Johnson did the sum as a joke: “As three to sixteen hundred, so is the proportion of an Englishman to a Frenchman.” Boswell dates the announcement of the Dictionary to 1747. It was published in 1755. Three years had become eight, and by Boswell’s account Johnson had spent the money while the work was still in progress.

He was late even on the prospectus. Johnson told Boswell that the published Plan of the Dictionary came to be addressed to Lord Chesterfield because “I had neglected to write it by the time appointed”, and the dedication was “a pretext for delay”. His own phrase for it was “a casual excuse for laziness”.

Then he did it again. In 1756 he issued proposals for an edition of Shakespeare and, Boswell writes, “promised his work should be published before Christmas, 1757. Yet nine years elapsed before it saw the light.” Subscribers had paid in advance. The satirist Charles Churchill mocked him in print: he “takes your cash; but where’s the book?” Boswell’s guess, and he marks it as a guess, is that the public embarrassment made Johnson’s friends push him to finish.

Promises to himself, with nobody waiting: broken, by his own account. In 1755 Johnson drew up a scheme for his Sundays. Item one was “To rise early”. Nine years later, on the night before Easter 1764, his diary lists his purposes again: “To avoid Idleness. To rise early.” That same year he wrote: “I have now spent fifty-five years in resolving; having, from the earliest time almost that I can remember, been forming schemes of a better life. I have done nothing.”

One detail from that Easter is easy to miss. At the altar he resolved, among other things, to study eight hours a day. He notes that he did so “in the presence of God, but without a vow”. He made the resolution and, in the same sentence, recorded that it was not binding.

Why it worked, and why it did not

This section is my reading of the record. Johnson never wrote a theory of his own deadlines, and one man’s life proves nothing on its own.

The kept promises had a person and a day. The Rambler had a printer expecting copy every Tuesday and Friday. The Idler essay had a post leaving in half an hour. Rasselas had a funeral to pay for. In each case somebody specific would notice, soon, if nothing arrived.

The late promises were huge and the date was far away. “A dictionary in three years” has no Tuesday in it. The work did get done, in an upper room in Gough Square that Boswell says was “fitted up like a counting-house”, with six copyists who were each handed their tasks. But the promise was made in the same way the thesis students made theirs: as a best case, stated with total confidence.

The broken promises had no collector at all. Nobody was waiting for Johnson to get out of bed. The resolution was large and vague (“avoid idleness”), it had no date, and the only witness was the man breaking it. When he did want something settled at once, he behaved quite differently. Asked how The Rambler got its name, he told Reynolds he sat on his bed one night and “resolved that I would not go to sleep till I had fixed its title”. His summary: “What must be done, Sir, will be done.” One task, one condition, tonight.

Money up front did not help. He had the Dictionary fee and the Shakespeare subscriptions in hand and was still years late on both. Being paid is not the same as being expected on Friday.

How to follow through on what you say you will do this week

This is Copy John’s adaptation of the pattern in Johnson’s record, not a system he laid out. He left deadlines and a diary, not a seven-day plan.

  1. List every open promise. Write down everything you have told anyone you will do, and everything you have told yourself. Include the vague ones (“we should get lunch”, “I’ll sort the garage”). Most people are carrying far more than they realised, which is the first reason things slip.
  2. Cancel or renegotiate the ones you will not keep. Go down the list and be honest. For anything you are not going to do, tell the person today and either hand it back or offer a smaller version. A promise withdrawn early costs a little trust. A promise silently dropped costs more. For the future, the cheapest follow-through is saying no at the start.
  3. Give each surviving promise a person and a day. Every item needs a name and a date: who receives it, and when. “Send Priya the draft by Thursday noon” is a promise. “Work on the draft” is a mood. For promises to yourself, appoint someone: a friend who gets a photo of the finished thing, or a class that starts at a fixed time.
  4. Cut the big ones into Rambler-sized pieces. Johnson was reliable at the twice-weekly essay and years late on the three-year book. If a promise is more than a week away, define the first piece that someone will receive this week.
  5. Double the time, then say the date out loud. Before you give a date, ask what your worst-case guess is, and remember the thesis students’ worst case was still too short. Quote the longer date. Delivering early never hurt anyone’s reputation.
  6. Write the when and where. Put each piece in the calendar as an if-then: “If it is Wednesday at 9am, then I write the summary at my desk before opening email.” A 2006 review of 94 tests by Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran found that if-then plans of this kind had a medium-to-large effect on whether people reached their goals.
  7. If you are going to miss, say so before the date. The moment you know, send the new date and the reason. Do not wait to be chased. Johnson’s subscribers waited years, and a poet made a joke of him in print.
  8. Count on Friday. Three numbers: promises kept, promises renegotiated in advance, promises broken. The aim for the first week is not a perfect score. It is to move items out of the third column into the second.

A note on telling people. Announcing a goal is not the same as having someone wait for it. In four experiments published in 2009, Peter Gollwitzer and colleagues found that when other people took notice of an identity-type intention (the example was a law student planning to study more), the person then acted on it less, apparently because being noticed already felt like progress. The studies covered that one kind of goal, so do not stretch them too far. But they fit the advice here: tell one person what they will receive and when, not an audience who you plan to become.

If the thing you keep not doing is a daily habit and not a one-off promise, our guide on how to build a habit that sticks covers Anthony Trollope’s daily quota and the diary he kept against himself.

What not to copy

The three-year boast. It makes a fine story because the Dictionary was finished. It was also an estimate out by years, made to a friend who had just told him it was unrealistic. When someone sensible asks “how can you do this in three years?”, the correct response is to check the plan, not to make a joke about the French.

Leaving it until the post is about to go. Writing an essay in half an hour worked for one of the most fluent prose writers in the language, on short pieces. It did not work for him on the long ones. Last-minute pressure is a deadline doing its job, not a technique to rely on.

Taking the money first. Johnson spent the Dictionary fee before the book was done and took Shakespeare subscriptions nine years before delivering. If you are paid in advance, the promise needs more structure, not less.

Reading his self-blame as laziness. The man who wrote “I have done nothing” had by then produced the Dictionary, The Rambler and Rasselas. His diary is a harsh and religious self-examination, not an accurate audit. Boswell also describes him in 1764 as severely ill with what was then called melancholy, “sighing, groaning, talking to himself”. If you cannot follow through on anything for weeks, and it comes with low mood, poor sleep or trouble concentrating that is new, that is worth a conversation with a doctor. A better calendar will not fix it.

Trusting every anecdote equally. Boswell met Johnson in 1763. The Dictionary conversation, the Rambler years and the Oxford story all reached him second-hand, from Johnson or from friends, years later. The dates of publication are solid. The exact words are as good as the memories of people who admired him.

Frequently asked questions

Why can’t I follow through with anything?

Usually because the promises have no recipient and no date, not because you lack character. Look at what you do keep: there is almost always a person waiting and a fixed day. Give the slipping promises the same two things. If the problem is new, affects everything and comes with low mood or poor concentration, see a doctor.

How do I follow through on commitments?

Make fewer of them, and make each one specific: what, to whom, by when. Put the first piece in your calendar with a time and a place. If you see you are going to miss, tell the person before the date and give a new one. That still counts as keeping your word.

How do I follow through on goals I set for myself?

Borrow a collector. Johnson kept promises a printer was waiting for and broke the ones only he knew about. Send a friend the finished piece every Friday, book a class, or pay for a session in advance. Keep the goal small enough that there is something to hand over each week.

What does “do what you say you will do” mean?

It means your statements about the future can be relied on: if you give a date, the thing arrives by that date, or the other person hears from you first. It does not mean never changing a plan. It means nobody finds out by silence.

Sources


This is part of Copy John’s guide to how to be more disciplined.

Get one of these a day, free →

More like this