How to stop making excuses: catch the sentence the moment you say it, check whether it changes the plan or just cancels it, and do a smaller version today instead. Seneca spotted the trick about 2,000 years ago. His letters list the excuses Romans used, and they are ours, word for word.

Why the usual advice fails
The standard advice is “take responsibility”. It is correct and nearly useless, because nobody making an excuse thinks they are making one. They think they are explaining. “I’m too tired tonight” does not feel like a dodge. It feels like a fact about your body.
The second piece of standard advice is “face your fears”. Also correct. Psychologists have a name for the fear part: self-handicapping. In a 1978 experiment, Steven Berglas and Edward Jones gave students either solvable or unsolvable problems, then told all of them they had done well. Before a retest, the students chose between a pill said to help performance and one said to hurt it. The men whose success had been unearned were the only group to prefer the pill that would hurt. The likely reason: if they failed next time, they could blame the drug instead of themselves. The effect did not show up in the women, so it is not a law of human nature. But it shows the shape of the thing. An excuse is often arranged in advance, to protect your opinion of yourself from a result.
So “stop being afraid” is not a plan either. What you need is a way to hear the excuse as it comes out of your mouth, and something to do instead. That is what the popular guides skip, and what a Roman politician wrote down in some detail.
What Seneca actually did
Lucius Annaeus Seneca was born in Corduba, in Spain, around 1 BC. He was exiled to Corsica in AD 41, came back to be the teenage Nero’s tutor, and served as one of Nero’s advisers after 54. According to the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, he wrote his Moral Letters to Lucilius in the last years of his life, roughly 62 to 65, after pulling back from court. In 65 Nero ordered him to kill himself.
The letters are addressed to a friend, Lucilius, and several of them are about excuses. Three are worth reading in full. They are short.
Letter 50: the blind woman who blamed the lighting. Seneca tells Lucilius about Harpaste, a clown who had belonged to his wife and stayed on in the house. She suddenly went blind and did not know it. She kept asking to be moved to other rooms, complaining that hers were too dark. Seneca admits the story sounds incredible and insists it is true. Then he turns it on everyone else. We all do this, he writes, and he lists how it sounds: “I am not self-seeking; but one cannot live at Rome in any other way.” “I am not extravagant, but mere living in the city demands a great outlay.” My temper and my lack of any settled plan for my life are “due to my youth”. Swap Rome for London and you have heard all three this month. His verdict: “Why do we deceive ourselves? The evil that afflicts us is not external, it is within us.” The letter closes with the practical point: the mind “must, therefore, be forced to make a beginning”.
Letter 17: “when I have enough”. Lucilius had written that he would take philosophy seriously once his estate was in order. Seneca quotes the excuse back to him and rejects it: “Away, then, with all excuses like: ‘I have not yet enough; when I have gained the desired amount, then I shall devote myself wholly to philosophy.’” The thing you keep putting second, he says, is the thing you should begin with. Replace philosophy with the gym, the novel or the business, and it is the most common excuse on earth: I’ll start when conditions are right.
Letter 28: you take yourself with you. Lucilius had travelled to shake off a low mood and it had not worked. Seneca’s reply: “You need a change of soul rather than a change of climate.” He passes on a line he credits to Socrates, that travel does not help “seeing that you always take yourself with you”. Then he gives the method, in one sentence. Quoting Epicurus, he says knowing you are at fault is the start of fixing it, so “prove yourself guilty, hunt up charges against yourself; play the part, first of accuser, then of judge, last of intercessor.”
That last instruction connects to the one habit Seneca describes himself keeping. In his essay On Anger (book III, chapter 36) he says the philosopher Sextius used to ask himself at bedtime what bad habit he had cured that day and in what way he was better. Seneca claims he does the same. When the lamp is taken away and his wife, “who knows my habit”, has stopped talking, he goes back over the whole day: “I conceal nothing from myself, and omit nothing.” Then he gives himself verdicts: you argued too hard there; you told that man off in a way that offended him instead of helping.
Why it worked
This section is my reading of the letters, not something Seneca wrote about his own results. Nobody recorded whether his nightly review changed him, and there is good reason, covered below, to doubt that it fully did.
It listens for the sentence, not the feeling. Seneca’s examples in Letter 50 are all quotations. He heard the excuse as a line of speech, which is exactly how you can catch it. “I would, but…” is audible. Guilt is vague.
It moves the cause inside. Every excuse on his list blames a place, a time or an age: Rome, the cost of living, youth. The Harpaste story is a joke about that. If the fault is in the room, the fix is a different room. If the fault is in you, moving house will not help, and Letter 28 says so plainly. That is the whole meaning of “take responsibility”, with a picture attached you will not forget.
It separates the prosecutor from the judge. Most people only play the third role in Letter 28, the intercessor, the lawyer for the defence. Seneca’s order matters. First you list the charges without arguing. Then you rule on them. Only then do you let yourself plead mitigation. An excuse is what happens when the defence speaks first.
It happens on a schedule. The review in On Anger happens at a fixed time, in the dark, when nobody is watching. An excuse that has to be explained to yourself every night gets harder to repeat, because you notice it has been used before.
It demands a start, not a resolution. “Forced to make a beginning”, in Letter 50. “Begin with it”, in Letter 17. And in Letter 1: “While we are postponing, life speeds by.” He never asks Lucilius to promise to change. He asks him to start.
How to stop making excuses this week
This is Copy John’s adaptation of the letters, not a routine Seneca laid out. He left principles and one described habit, not a seven-day plan.
- Keep an excuse log for two days. Every time you say or think “I would, but…”, write the sentence down exactly as it came out. Do not argue with it yet. You are the accuser at this stage, collecting charges. Most people find the same three or four sentences on repeat.
- Run the reason-or-excuse test on each one. This test is ours, not Seneca’s. A reason changes the plan; an excuse cancels it. “My knee hurts, so I’ll swim instead of run” is a reason. “My knee hurts, so not this week”, with no swim booked, is probably an excuse. Ask: is it true, and does it come with a new plan attached?
- Find the Rome in each sentence. Underline the outside thing being blamed: the boss, the weather, the kids, the city, your age. Then rewrite the sentence with you as the subject. “I don’t have time” becomes “I chose to spend the time on something else”. It might still be the right choice. At least now it is a choice.
- Attach a minimum to every recurring excuse. For the excuses that keep coming back, write an if-then plan in advance: “If I’m too tired to run, then I walk for ten minutes.” A 2006 review of 94 tests by Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran found these if-then plans had a medium-to-large effect on reaching goals. The minimum removes the excuse’s power to cancel.
- Kill one “when I have enough”. Pick the thing you are waiting on conditions for, as in Letter 17, and do the smallest real piece of it today. One page, one call, one session. Seneca’s point is that the thing you keep putting last should go first.
- Review the day in three lines at bedtime. Our version of the review in On Anger. What excuse did I use today? Was it a reason or an excuse? What will I do instead tomorrow? Three lines on paper, two minutes, lights out. Hear the defence last.
- On day seven, count. Look at the log. If an excuse appeared three or more times, it is a habit, not an event. Give it a standing if-then plan and keep going for another week.
If the same excuse is about discipline in general rather than one task, our guide on how to build self discipline when you have none covers William James’s habit rules for starting from zero.
What not to copy
The idea that Seneca lived what he wrote. He did not, at least not neatly. Tacitus reports (Annals 13.42) that an enemy, Publius Suillius, attacked him in public: by what philosophy had Seneca made three hundred million sesterces in four years of imperial favour? That was an accusation from a man on trial, not an audit, but Seneca was undeniably very rich while writing about living simply. He seems to have known it. In Letter 27 he tells Lucilius he is not curing him from a position of health, but talking “as if we were lying ill in the same hospital”. Take the method. Do not take him as a saint.
Treating the letters as a diary. The Stanford Encyclopedia notes that scholars read the letters as a crafted literary persona, not straight autobiography. Harpaste may be real, embroidered or a teaching story. The advice works either way, but do not quote it as a documented event in the way you would quote a dated journal entry.
“At times be harsh with yourself”, as a lifestyle. Seneca says it at the end of Letter 28. A nightly trial where the verdict is always guilty is not discipline, it is rumination. Keep the review short, end it with one thing to do tomorrow, and stop. If you find you cannot stop the self-criticism, or it comes with weeks of low mood, that is a conversation for a doctor, not a habit to push through.
Calling every reason an excuse. Illness, caring for someone, money you really do not have: these are real limits. The test in step 2 exists so you can tell them apart. A real reason changes the plan. It does not have to cancel it.
Frequently asked questions
How to stop making excuses for yourself?
Write down the exact sentence each time you use one, for two days. Then check each sentence: does it change the plan or cancel it? Anything that only cancels gets a minimum version you do anyway. Seneca’s version was a bedtime review of the day in which he says he concealed nothing from himself.
How to stop making excuses and take responsibility?
Rewrite each excuse with you as the subject. “The city makes me spend” becomes “I spend”. That is the move in Seneca’s Letter 50, where every excuse blames Rome or youth and he answers that the fault is “within us”. Responsibility is not guilt. It just means the fix is also in your hands.
How to stop making excuses for others?
Use the same test on their behaviour. If you keep explaining away what someone does (“he’s just stressed”), ask whether the explanation changes what you expect from them or quietly cancels it. If the same excuse has covered the same behaviour for months, it is no longer an explanation. It is a pattern, and it is worth saying so to them directly.
How to stop making excuses for working out?
Set an if-then minimum before the excuse arrives: “If I skip the gym, I do ten minutes at home.” Excuses cancel; a minimum only shrinks the session. Our piece on how to be consistent with working out shows how the strongman Eugen Sandow set a minimum effort for bad days in his own book.
Sources
- Seneca, Moral Letters to Lucilius, Letter 50, “On our blindness and its cure”, trans. Richard Mott Gummere (Wikisource): Harpaste and the list of excuses (sections 2 to 4), “forced to make a beginning” (section 9).
- Letter 17, “On philosophy and riches”: “Away, then, with all excuses” (section 5).
- Letter 28, “On travel as a cure for discontent”: change of soul, Socrates, accuser, judge, intercessor (sections 1, 2, 9, 10).
- Letter 27, “On the good which abides”: “lying ill in the same hospital” (section 1).
- Letter 1, “On saving time”: “While we are postponing, life speeds by” (section 2).
- Seneca, Of Anger, book III, trans. Aubrey Stewart, 1900 (Wikisource): Sextius and Seneca’s bedtime review (chapter XXXVI).
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, “Seneca”, section 1, Life and Works: dates, exile, Nero, the letters written 62 to 65, literary persona.
- Tacitus, Annals, book 13, trans. Church and Brodribb (Wikisource): Suillius’s accusation (chapter 42).
- Berglas and Jones, “Drug choice as a self-handicapping strategy in response to noncontingent success”, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 36 (1978).
- Gollwitzer and Sheeran, “Implementation Intentions and Goal Achievement: A Meta-analysis of Effects and Processes”, Advances in Experimental Social Psychology 38 (2006).
This is part of Copy John’s guide to how to be more disciplined.
Get one of these a day, free →
More like this
- How to Build Self Discipline When You Have None: William James’s 1870 notebook and the habit rules he wrote twenty years later.
- How to Be a More Disciplined Man: Marcus Aurelius and Theodore Roosevelt on not waiting to feel like it.
- How to Build a Habit That Sticks: Anthony Trollope’s quota and the diary he could not argue with.
- How to Follow Through on What You Say You Will Do: Samuel Johnson’s kept and missed deadlines, sorted by who was waiting.
- How to Be Disciplined Without Motivation: Jack London’s daily stint, and the reward that took it over.
